While any sensible angler knows there is no such thing as "The Magic Bait", there are some types of lure that have a magical quality by their application, action, and dynamic response of the prey the user is seeking, that can almost qualify them as supernatural in their ability to produce memorable, if not mind blowing strikes. Enter the Topwater Plug. While it is arguably not the best bait in many situations, in the right place, time, and light conditions there are few that can claim it's awesome power to call fish to the chow line, sometimes with violently acrobatic results. In my experience, never pass up a chance to throw a topwater bait early in the a.m. before the sun is over the treetops, on a cloudy day, especially if there is a medium breeze or light rain, and as night falls. If you have some loud lures even night fishing can bring success.
Above are six examples of one of the most popular topwater plug of all time, the Heddon Zara Spook. Introduced in 1939 these floating, rattling lures have a long history of grabbing Bass, Largemouth and Smallmouth, Pike, Pickerel, and even Catfish once in a blue moon. The Zara Spook is 4 1/2" long and weighs 3/4 oz. making it a bullet to cast with reasonable accuracy. This size comes with two 1/0 treble hooks that will hold once properly set. The trick to properly securing a hook set is staying calm and patient for about two seconds after the strike, once the fish hits and the water surface is splashed you need to be able to be sure the bait has been taken. You need to see the line move ( if there is any slack in it) , or feel the fish pull. This may seem easy in the reading, but when your heart skips a beat and your breath catches at the unexpected strike it is easy to jerk the rod, find the fish just slapped the bait and find you and your fishing buddy ducking a steel hook-laden missile. This will take practice and will result in some lost fish, but remember the two second rule. Train yourself to wait, and when you feel the fish on, apply steady, hard pressure to the rod keeping the tip down so the fish will be less inclined to jump and free itself with an aerial head shake, and do not let up on the pressure until you have the fish lipped or in the net. A word to the wise, with multi-hook lures, always have a good set of stainless steel needle nose pliers handy. For your sake as well as the fish's.
The four baits on the left are Berkley Frenzy Walkers, 1/2 oz. and 4" they rattle, and have a thicker body diameter than the Zara Spook, come with similar size dual hooks and because of their formed body shape, have a different action than the Spook. The two on the left are called 'pencils', the black one is by Tsunami, the silver scale is by a new company who's name escapes me at the moment. These pencils have a sharper side to side action than Walkers or Spooks by virtue of their tapered tail. More on the pencil later. By action I mean how you 'walk' the lure over the surface of the water, a technique that is not hard to learn with a little practice. Cast the bait out far into open water and let it rest a few seconds. Hold the rod tip at between 7 and 8 o'clock with a little slack in the line, then snap your wrist away from the direction of the lure about 2" or 4" at a time, and crank the reel handle 1/2 to 2/3 of a revolution. Sounds simple, and may take a few tries but picture the bait snapping from side to side as it retrieves. Learn a steady pace first, then you can vary the return, sharp rapid snaps with a fast retrieve if the bite is aggressive, a slower cadence and crawl if the fish are spooky or you are fishing a pressured body of water. Advice, a baitcasting reel is superior for topwater lures as the slack line for the snapping motion that makes the lure 'walk' does not translate to fouling loops as it will in the spool of a spinning reel! Authors note: The Berkley Frenzy line of lures was discontinued last year. About the only place to find them now is in the discount bin, or Ebay where they can still be had for a fair price.
There are more varieties of topwater baits available than I can count. Different shapes and sizes have appeal to different species, and the same species at different times of the year or spawning cycle. Above left, a Heddon Excaliber Spit n' Image in Bass pattern, with a wide deep body and rattle that while only a little over 3" long, displaces a lot of water as it moves. Below left is a Rapala Skitterwalk in bluegill colors, 3 1/8" long, and 7/16oz. For its size it is the loudest rattling surface bait I own. The next three on the right are 'pencil' baits, the top two are Spro Dawg 100's, with rattles and dressed rear trebles, the bottom in black and red is a Yozuri pencil walker, with a fine high pitched rattle. The Spro and Yozuri lures are both 4", and 1/2 oz.. The allure of the pencil bait is it's delicate movement, the tail being thinner and less buoyant sits lower in the water and allows for better hookup. These finer body baits also have their application in hi pressured waters where the fish see the same shape swimming overhead all day. These walkers take a very supple wrist and a little less retrieve speed for the most consistent action.
Presented here are six examples of the Heddon Super Spook jr. A smaller cousin to the Zara Spook, these measure 3 1/2", and weigh 1/2 oz. They cast just as well as their larger counterparts above, with the exception of some distance depending on the line you use. For this size and smaller topwater I use a 12 lb. copolymer or monofilament. ( avoid fluorocarbons as is sinks and will hinder the action of the plug) For anything larger I like braided line for the long cast and damage resistance, from 20 lb., 35lb., to 65lb. test.
Here are some of the most productive size baits of this genre. The top two rows are various patterns of the Heddon Zara Puppy. They are 3" and only 1/4 oz. so need to be handled with finesse. I love to throw them into 6" of water near shore cover, to the edge of lily pads and over openings in submerged weed banks and let them sit for a few minutes, this alone brings curiosity strikes from fish you might not have expected to be in the vicinity. These require more care and skill to 'walk' than even pencil baits and do not rattle. They are a true stealth bait, but do not think larger fish will not pay them attention, they seem to appear much like a tasty snack looking for a consumer. Bottom left, a 2" version on the Heddon Excaliber Spit n' Image with rattle. Bottom middle a modified bait, a Heddon Teeny Torpedo, with the propeller (usually found on the screw holding the trailing treble hook) removed for a sneakier retrieve, this little bait is 1 1/2", and only 1/8 oz. Bottom right is a Baby Zara, now discontinued this 2" non-rattling plug 'walks' in a more twitchy fashion than its longer brothers, giving the fish a new picture to look at.Authors note: Ebay is still the best source for older and discontinued baits. If you intend to fish them, as I do, bid on the used lures, and leave the perfect condition baits with matching boxes to the collectors. One day one of those classic specimens may be reproduced for retail sale for your grandchildren to enjoy!
Now for my personal favorites. I have come to appreciate the long casting ability, noise, and displacement of water endemic to larger topwater lures. Granted they catch fewer fish as they can be intimidating to some species, but when you are hit hard on a bait that weighs over 1 1/2oz. and is 6" to 9" long you know you may be in for the fight of your life, and possibly the biggest fish you have ever hooked. Surprisingly price varies greatly with larger lures. The top lure in this photo is an Evergreen Amazon Pencil. At over 6" and 1 2/3 oz. it is a bulky lure, and has two sets of rattles and three black chrome 1/0 hooks. From Japan a special order will cost $24.99 US., I got mine on Ebay for $4.oo. The two Renegade lures below are 5", over 1oz. and have very loud rattles and a metallic scale finish. These can be had for less than $3.00 US in some retail stores and on Ebay. As they are excessively loud, they make good bait for night fishing.Below are some of my next favorites. The six cigar shaped lures are Heddon Super Spooks, 5" long and 7/8 oz. with good rattles. They have 3 No.2 treble hooks, some anglers remove the first set back from the nose, as on occasion it can foul the line during a cast. This is a matter of preference, I leave mine on and seldom foul. Let your experience be the judge. These also cast a mile and make a lot of commotion on the water. While generally sold as saltwater baits I have had little problem getting interested Bass, pike, and pickerel to take a turn at the attack. The plug at the center of the photo is a custom I painted to replicate the Tiger Salamander, a native amphibian here in Massachusetts. While not a regular part of Bass diet, all Bass seem to have a genetically encoded hatred for salamanders of any kind as they eat Bass eggs , so you can imagine the animosity involved in a strike on this lure. On the upper left is a bait common in the Northern-Midwestern US called a Suick, primarily used for Muskie and Pike it is a wooden bait that one pulls in snaps across the water, the underside of the front portion of the lure is concave so sends water splashing to the sides. The flexible metal 'tail' can be bent up or down to make the bait dip into the water or pop out of it on the snap retrieve. The Suick is 7" long and about 1 1/2 oz, and comes with 2 No.3 heavy duty hooks. So ends this first installment on lures, over time there will be more on a wide variety of what we fish with here in New England. Feel free to post any questions, I am sure I missed points, and hope to hear any tips, and accounts of the baits you use where you fish.
Good fishing and God bless, Mike.
















